Marine and coastal areas face major challenges: climate change, biodiversity loss, pollution, and extreme weather events all create challenges for those responsible for managing these areas. Some of the issues have been on the agenda for decades, which is a sign that solutions are far from straightforward. Through the BlueGreen Governance (BGG) project, we are investigating what is needed to better align land and marine governance.
Before looking at solutions, it is important to clearly identify the challenges in regions and the barriers standing in the way of institutional change. We want to illustrate these challenges and barriers using video quotes from the members of our team.
Environmental challenges
Climate change
Coastal regions are also facing problems that are becoming more urgent as the climate changes. Due to extreme weather events, changing ecosystems and other environmental pressures, governance cannot simply respond to problems as they arise – it also needs to anticipate possible future developments. This adds new uncertainties to already complex governance situations.
Watch Cory Fletcher’s speech about flood safety programs in the Netherlands and Belgium.
Environmental degradation and pollution
Pollution and runoff from entire river basins, the loss of apex predators due to fishing, and habitat alteration caused by coastal development result in cumulative effects that are difficult to reverse using current tools. The Oslo Fjord is a striking example of this: despite a wide range of plans, ecological decline persists, partly because the combined impact of all these various activities is not clearly understood. The area has significant contamination, eutrophication due to an overload of nutrients, and local fisheries that are a key concern in the area.
Watch Gunnar Sander speech the Oslofjord.
Also watch the video with Nestor Mareno Rodriguez about the environmental issues in the case study Canary Islands.
Barriers to good governance
The moment a government seeks to address these challenges, new ones arise. We are referring to the barriers that stand in the way of good governance. The barriers are nicely summarized in the video at the bottom of the article.
Fragmented policies
Marine and coastal governance is often characterized by fragmented policies and responsibilities. Different institutions are responsible for different parts of the same area, while policies for land, coasts and marine environments are frequently developed in isolation from one another. The lack of alignment between policy objectives, geographical scales and timelines further complicates coordination. For example, marine and freshwater policies often operate under different frameworks and planning cycles, causing important land-sea interactions to be overlooked.
Institutional design
The way governance systems are organised can itself become a barrier to change. Overlapping mandates, unclear responsibilities, siloed organisations and complex administrative structures can slow decision-making and hinder coordination. Governance arrangements that have developed over time are often difficult to adapt, even when environmental and societal challenges require new approaches. Effective management therefore depends not only on good policies, but also on institutions that are able to collaborate across sectors and governance levels.
A good example of institutional design being a barrier is the Canary Islands. The different levels of governance in the area are plenty: municipal, regional, insular and national. All these governance levels have to reach an agreement in order to solve the problems that the area is facing, which is very difficult. This creates a lot of issues, for example lack of project funding.
Participatory access
Although participation is widely recognised as essential for effective governance, meaningful engagement is not always easy to achieve. Opportunities for participation may exist only formally, while some stakeholders remain difficult to reach or insufficiently represented. Differences in resources, knowledge, power and access can create barriers to involvement, making it harder to build trust, incorporate local knowledge and develop broadly supported solutions. Inclusive participation is therefore a key condition for governance that is both effective and legitimate.
Watch Uyen explain the three barriers to good governance in coastal and marine regions.
Better view on barriers
These are the barriers in broad outline. In a subsequent blog, we will elaborate further on these barriers—such as fragmentation, a lack of long-term planning, inadequate participation, etc.